Tuesday, April 22, 2025

Pi Network Review

 



Available for Android and iOSSign up with our referral code ( ministerkataoka) to get a starting Pi token bonus and mining boost


First introduced in 2019, the Pi Network celebrated a major milestone with listing of its cryptocurrency on exchanges for the first time in early 2025. The most basic "work" in this case consists of tapping a button once per day, but is it even worth that much effort?


NATURE OF WORK AND PAYMENT


Pi isn't so much "microwork" as it is "crypto mining." However, it's unique in a couple of ways. Crypto mining usually means setting up some beefy rig to mine something very valuable like Bitcoin. Pi was designed from the start to be simple and work on common devices like phones without putting a strain on them, allowing even very basic hardware to participate. It's also gradually building a whole ecosystem that offers other earning opportunities, such as apps that can be built and run on its chain. 

The other big difference from other types of crypto mining: you don't actually have to use your compute power or utilities! Think of it more like one of those old Bitcoin faucets instead of a mining setup, except that's how the creators set the whole structure up from the beginning. Once every 24 hours, you tap the "mine" button. You're now gradually mining at your preset rate (determined by a number of factors, more on that later) for that whole period regardless of what you do: minimize the app, close it completely, turn the device off if you want. All you have to do is come back after 24 hours and hit the "mine" button again to start another cycle. The whole existing supply of Pi is pre-minted, and you just gradually get your share by showing up and verifying that you've hit the button once per day. 



So wait, what's to stop someone from buying a billion cheap devices and just pushin' the button on all of them once per day? A "know your customer" (KYC) identity verification requirement to actually move or use your minings, that ties your personal identity to that one particular account. You can freely move your account to new devices simply by logging in, but doing that on multiple devices doesn't help you at all (you just get the one check-in per account per day). 

Long-term, the overall system is that the earlier you get in and mine the more your Pi is worth. Whenever the network user count increases by a factor of 10, the base Pi mining rate gets halved. There is a total all-time maximum supply of 100 billion tokens. 

The one "work" element to this basic process is that you will sometimes randomly have to watch an ad after hitting your mining button for the day. This seems to be about a 50/50 chance, and the ad is the standard sort of thing you see in "freemium" mobile games and is usually easily skipped out of in short order.


SITE HISTORY / LEGITIMACY

Pi Network got its start in early 2019, and for a long while people thought it was gonna wind up being nothing more than pie-in-the-sky as it had a number of ups and downs through the early 20s. But it's a legit project backed by legit funding, and almost exactly six years later it finally took its big "Phase 3" step of beginning to be listed on cryptocurrency exchanges. 

After all this time, and tens of millions of users across the world, it's definitely not a scam and really doesn't appear to be in any danger of collapse at this point. The only question is how far it will go and how much its tokens will end up being worth. 


INTERNATIONAL ACCESS

Pi Network is available globally, but as part of the KYC process you may have to prove you are at least 18 years old. This involves submitting a photo of a valid government-issued ID through the app that demonstrates your name, date of birth and residential address.

All users will eventually have to do KYC or lose their accumulated Pi, but for many people the process has been paused until at least the end of 2025 as they apparently do not have the manpower or system in place to check all of these 10s of millions of IDs. The "Mainnet" tab in the app will tell you what your deadline is, if you're able to proceed through all the steps at this point, and provide links to the steps that are left. There is an "expedited" KYC method by creating an account with some sort of partner called "Banxa" and spending $20 USD to purchase Pi there, but apparently this is not available in all countries and there are several US states it cannot be done from as well.

There are some restrictions on nations using Pi, but the official FAQ page is cagey about exactly who and where. News articles indicate China is heavily restricted from trading and selling. Some of this may have to do with regional laws that ban all types of crypto, such as those in Thailand. But as of this writing, the biggest problem is a limited list of exchanges that it is listed on that are not available in every country. You can always mine and hold onto it and hope things change in the future, but for now there are some parts of the world where you can't do very much with it. 


STARTING OUT


Starting out is about as easy as it gets - find the Pi Network app on the Android or Apple app store and install. It's small and easy to deal with, and the Android one will install and work fine for Chromebook users. 

You can begin mining and accumulating immediately just by connecting a valid email address to your account and receiving a verification email. But, as mentioned above, for transactions you'll need to complete KYC steps and at the moment you might not be able to complete the full list for some months. 

You can keep it as simple as just tapping the button every 24 hours to mine, but there are some added earning opportunities. You can boost your mining rate by adding up to five other miners to your "Security Circle." The idea with this is that it should be people you personally know in real life, and their phone number will need to be in your phone contacts to add them. It's also best to add people who have either done KYC already or you are certain are going to when it becomes available. 

Another quick boost to your mining rate is to set a "lockup period." This is essentially kind of like staking; you set a percentage of your Pi that will become ineligible for transfer for a while, and a length of duration (from one month up to several years), and the greater the commitment the more of a mining boost you receive. The highest possible boost is 200% at the moment. 

There is also a more general referral system, called the "Ambassador" program (you can join via our referral link here or use code " ministerkataoka "). Every new referral provides a 25% boost to your current base rate during the time periods you and that person are both actively mining. There is no limit to referrals, and there is one additional incentive to this program: if a referral ends up developing and launching a Pi app, you get a one-time 1,000 Pi bonus! As a new user, if you sign up using someone's referral code, you get a 1.25 Pi bonus to start out. 

What was that about apps? Pi Network allows for decentralized app development and use through its own main app, via the partner app Pi Browser. This allows for an opportunity to use Pi as currency, some examples that are presently running are retail storefronts and a bunch of games including a poker app. However, this feature only just launched and as of this writing the ecosystem and apps are in a pretty rough and rudimentary state. 

Don't want to develop an app? Or gamble? No problem. You can get a sporadic "utility bonus" from spending time just using the various Pi apps and the Fireside message board. 

And if you have some hardware to devote to the task and some home internet to spare, you can run a Pi node. This is more like traditional Bitcoin-type mining and is a bit more involved, but the upside is it can be done on very modest (and fairly old) computers so you may well have a device laying around already fit for the task. Just note that this also requires you to separately check in and push a button once every 24 hours to keep it running. 


PROBLEMS WITH PI NETWORK


At least at the moment, you're still really on your own for figuring everything out (even after six years of development). There's no real "tech support" to speak of beyond a few unpaid volunteers you might be able to chat or message with. While the app is fairly well-designed, a lot of aspects are not really self-explanatory and require tracking down outside explanation - including one of the most fundamental things, how to view the Pi you've mined and the difference between in being in the app and in your wallet! The project is also in the midst of the mainnet "migration" and it's really not well-explained to new users what that is or if there is something they need to personally do. 

Unless you take the paid Banxa shortcut, finishing the KYC process requires you to wait to get a "slot" (basically an appointment) to do it. Some people are reporting waits of 1 to 3 years to get a slot! However, others with relatively new accounts say it's only taken several months. Personally I've only been using it for about two months and have heard nothing about this yet.


FINAL VERDICT - HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

If you have an Apple or Android device, there's really no reason not to install this and at minimum just tap the button once per day. It's possible it could amount to no more than a few USD in the end, but there's always the chance that years from now you could be sitting on hundreds to thousands from this minimal effort. 

The big question is, of course, how much is it gonna be worth? At the moment, since it began listing on crypto exchanges around two months ago, it's fluctuated between about 50 to 80 cents USD per coin. Long-term, who knows. The future value seems to primarily hinge on people adopting it as a payment method. It has unique potential in the fact that its user base will eventually be entirely KYC'd, something not done with nearly all other types of crypto. I'm no expert, but from a general survey of a couple of discussion forums the very optimistic view seems to be $100 USD per coin in a few years. $1000 per coin would be the long shot pie-in-the-sky if there's some sort of incredible luck within the next 10 years. But hey, it's an easy and simple long-term gamble at no real risk and about the most minimum effort possible.



Links


Friday, February 14, 2025

What is CaptchaCoin? Is It Legit?



CaptchaCoin is a unique cryptocurrency project. The simplest explanation is that you solve "select the correct image" captchas and earn crypto tokens for doing it. If that sounds too good to be true, it's because it really isn't *quite* that simple; it's an experimental project still in its very early stages, and right now the money is essentially in ground-floor investment of your time rather than putting anything in your pocket in the near term. 

Is CaptchaCoin Legit?

I first stumbled across CaptchaCoin in November 2024, but apparently it's been operational since sometime in 2022. At this point I'm 95% confident it's not some kind of an elaborate scam, but it is a very experimental idea that might ultimately amount to pie-in-the-sky. 

But one of the chief reasons I believe it's not a scam is that there's almost nothing to spend money on, and it's completely free-to-use and free-to-earn. The captchas are also generated and solved within CaptchaCoin's own ecosystem, for the purpose of "strengthening its blockchain" somehow; you're not solving captchas for third parties or other websites or anything like that. This page explains more about the technical details of what solving captchas does for CaptchaCoin's own chain. 

Basically, you can invest a small amount of easy labor for what might turn out to be a considerable reward later. The project does not offer any guarantees of anything, and I can see several ways in which it might eventually fall apart, but right now it's roughly analogous to working Bitcoin faucets 15 years ago before anyone had any idea it would turn into anything.  

What is CaptchaCoin?

The project's litepaper provides a much more detailed overview, but I'll try to summarize the main points. At the retail "money-making" end the purpose is to eventually transition to a captcha system used by websites and apps to verify human users, and also to be listed as a general cryptocurrency in and of itself. At the user end, at least for now in the "pre-launch" phase, you solve sets of captchas and get chunks of coins in return.

What can you do with the coins? Well, for now, not much. Once you start mining coins, you'll see some eye-popping estimates of what they'll be worth (presumably in USD) once the launch phase begins. At the moment they can be traded via Litecoin through the website, but the current going price is a whole lot more modest. The estimated launch price seems to be about $15-ish per coin, but current trading prices are at more like 10 cents per coin. 

One of its more interesting features is that you don't necessarily have to personally mine to earn coins. The project offers tools for embedding a sort of "paywall" on web pages or apps to have users do a little mining to gain access to your content,  a feature I'll dive deeper into a little later in the post. 

Getting Started With CaptchaCoin

Another one of CaptchaCoin's central selling points is accessibility; it's meant to be a simplified form of crypto with fewer knowledge barriers to getting started in earning and trading. 

Getting started is simply a matter of choosing a username and password, and you can optionally set an email address for account recovery purposes. You don't need the password to mine, just to do anything related to transactions to or from your wallet. 

You have a basic mining mode, and then a few other more exotic options for earning coins. Let's cover the standard mining mode first. You're presented with a screen full of scrambled images, and have to pick the "most clear" of them. This has gone through several different changes but seems to have settled on picking either a spiral or orb image at this point. You have to get six of these correct in a row (a "solve") to mine a percentage of a coin, which changes over time. As of this writing it's about .04 coins per solve, so it takes about 25 solves or 150 individual clicks on images to earn a full coin. 

There are some alternative mining modes that have their advantages and disadvantages. One is called "competitive mining," in which you're seeing a screen of images that someone else might also be seeing. First person to click on the right image takes the pot, and you get more than the usual rate for winning this battle. However, this mode disappeared for an "update" back around December 2024 and hasn't come back since. 

Another alternative mining mode is "diamond mining." With this mode, each individual solve nets you a random amount. There is a table showing a fixed percentage possibility, ranging from getting absolutely nothing to a whopping 10,000 coins. But the most likely result for any solve, and the only ones I've personally gotten so far, is to get a fragment of a coin ranging from .01 to .75. This can make earning move along faster with a little luck, but there's a big downside to this mode - you don't earn "logs" while doing it. 

Logs are another central concept that's important to understand. You earn these alongside coins with your mining, but only in the "regular" mining mode. Logs are needed to make wallet transactions, it's essentially the "gas fee" of this coin. But the important part to understand is that if you don't earn any logs within a 24 hour period, they start decaying (disappearing). Coins will never disappear, but logs can disappear on you quickly without any mining activity. 

Diamond Mining


CaptchaCoin "Casino Modes"

CaptchaCoin also has a small "casino" section, but there's no actual gambling. Instead there are several games: a lottery, the "irrational game," and a "random mining" mode that looks like it was the precursor of "diamond mining" and may be deprecated now as it doesn't seem to work. 

The lottery has you mine for lottery tickets in a slightly different mode, where you pick an image containing readable letters then type in what the letters are. When you do this successfully it now says you earned "0 tickets" but if you look in your wallet it actually did give you a ticket for each correct solve ... I just don't have any idea if or when the drawing is going to be, as I think I still have tickets from three months ago sitting around. This mode is also problematic as you sometimes either get blocks where none of the text is fully readable, or it appears readable but it keeps insisting you're typing in the wrong letters. 

Earning lottery tickets


The "irrational game" is the only one that requires you to bet some coin, specifically 0.89 coins right now to play. It's a little hard to explain but it seems kind of like last-minute bid sniping on eBay, you can see the full rules broken down here

Options for Content Creators

As previously touched on, one of the most interesting aspects of this project is that you don't have to personally mine to earn. At least two options for content creators to embed CaptchaCoin features on their sites have been announced thus far: Tip Jars and the CapWall.

The tip jar is pretty simple, you can create a personalized link to add to your content while in your CaptchaCoin account. Users follow a link that goes to a one-off captcha solve that contributes a coin chunk to the creator's account. You can try it out at this link if you feel like leaving us a tip!

The other feature is the really interesting one. The CapWall lets you create a mining instance on your web page that acts as a paywall for content. Instead of paying up, users simply do a little mining to unlock your content, and the proceeds go to your CaptchaCoin account. However, after playing with it a little bit, it doesn't seem to actually work yet.

Questions About CaptchaCoin

While I do think the project is legitimate and has potential, the documentation of features/functions and transparency could definitely use some improvement. I can also see at least a couple possible major points of failure that could wreck the whole thing. These are my concerns about it:

> It's a "you don't actually own your wallet" situation right now, not a true cryptocurrency. Everything is handled through the captchacoin.net website. So at any time, as far as I can tell, your earnings could disappear or be locked off for a number of reasons: devs just up and quit on the project, technical issues ... also hacking as there's no indication how robust the security is. Supposedly everything done through the website is backed by a blockchain somewhere, but you kinda just have to take their word for it at this point.

> It seems to be relying on the inability of AI to recognize images well enough to solve the captchas. That's something that the world's biggest tech companies are dumping huge research money into constantly, however. If AI starts solving the captchas, does that render the project obsolete?

> A Telegram group is listed as the main source for new announcements, but if you check it out it's just a sprawling 24/7 group chat that's usually about other crypto stuff and whatever else. I'm not sure how to tease out the important announcements from all the blather. Telegram is also kind of a headache in general if you don't already use it anyway, first it has to be installed on a phone and associated with that phone's number to let you in, THEN you can use the desktop client with the number (via SMS verification every time) to browse ... big pain just to keep up with news. There are also official X and Reddit accounts but they seem to be updated much less frequently (gaps of months between posts right now).

> While you have to do some sort of mining every 24 hours to stop logs from decaying, it's not clear exactly how much. Is one click on an image good enough? One solve? I saw an offhand comment on Telegram indicating you need to mine an entire coin per day, but I have no idea if that's true or not. If it is, mining one coin is very manageable right now (maybe 5-10 minutes or so of clicking), but it just continues to get harder over time and presumably it won't be eventually. 

Should You Give CaptchaCoin a Try?

As mentioned, I'm fairly certain this isn't a scam as there are much quicker and easier ways to run a scamcoin that don't involve years of indirect buildup and all this elaborate website stuff and paper-writing (just ask Hawk Tuah). But it's an apparently one-man or several-man shoestring project that could very well fall apart in a number of ways. The upside is that, at least at this point, you only need to invest a little time here and there to potentially earn some decent money, and if the thing goes kablooey that's all you're out in the end. And even if it never goes far beyond the current trading price of about 10 cents per coin, that still might be useful money for those in developing countries at least. 


Links

Block explorer

Forum post laying out the long-term plan in non-technical language

CaptchaCoin Reddit account

X/Twitter account